Congress Program
(This program may be amended; an updated version
will be distributed or amendments made as appropriate.)
Sunday, October 21, 2001
1500-1900 Registration and Information Desk Open
Palm Room
Monday, October 22, 2001
0800-1700 Registration and Information Desk Open
Palm Room
0930-1000 Opening Ceremony
Starlight Roof
Opening Remarks: David W. Martowski
President, Society of Maritime Arbitrators
Welcome: Richard M. Larabee
Director, Port Commerce of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey
Invocation: Reverend Peter Larom
Executive Director
Seamen’s Church Institute
Introduction: Austin L. Dooley, PhD
Starlight Roof
Chair: R. Glenn Bauer
Timekeeper: H.M. Singh
1. SUMMARY OF IMPORTANT RECENT SMA DECISIONS
Howard H. McCormack (USA)
presented by John D. Kimball
2. THE ARBITRATION ACT 1996 – DEVELOPMENTS IN THE COURTS
Bruce Harris (UK)
OTHER METHODS OF DISPUTE RESOLUTION AND VIEWS ON EACH OF THE CHIEF ARBITRATION CENTERS
Terence Coghlin (UK)
4. MARITIME ARBITRATION IN HONG KONG POST 1997
Robin Peard (Hong Kong SAR)
5. A SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT AWARDS PUBLISHED BY CAMP
Jean Jacques Ollu (France)
6. COMPARISON BETWEEN LONDON AND NEW YORK TO COMMODITY ARBITRATIONS
Patrick V. Martin (USA) and David Pullen (UK)
>Questions from the floor<
Palm Room
Hilton Room
1415-1730 Concurrent Session II - Maritime Arbitration: Jurisdiction and
Starlight Roof New Areas
Chair: Raymond J. Burke
Timekeeper: Chandran Arul
1. JURISDICTION OVER NON-SIGNATORIES TO THE ARBITRATION
AGREEMENT – CAN ARBITRATORS PIERCE THE CORPORATE VEIL?
Mike R. Pimm (UK)
2. ARBITRATION – WHETHER YOU INTEND IT OR NOT – HOW SIGNATORIES AND NO-SIGNATORIES ALIKE MAY BE ESTOPPED FROM AVOIDING ARBITATION
Tulio R. Prieto (USA)
3. THE ENFORCEMENT OF FOREIGN ARBITRATION AWARDS IN THE UNITED ARAB EMIRATES
Alec Emmerson (UAE) – presented by Corrina Creswell
4. ISSUES TO BE ADDRESSED AS SPACE OR SLOT CHARTERS SEE EXPANDED USE IN THE LINER TRADES
John P. Vayda (USA)
5. INCORPORATION OF CONTRACT TERMS INTO MARITIME CONTRACTS
Nicholas Walser
6. THE EMERGENCE OF MEDIATION AS A MEANS OF DISPUTE RESOLUTION IN MARITIME MATTERS
Clive Aston (UK)
>Questions from the floor<
1415-1730 Concurrent Session III - Arbitral Development, Past, Present, and Elsewhere, Ethics and Ideas
Chair: Patrick O’Donovan
Timekeeper: Rucemah Pereira
1. AN 1826 NEW YORK MARITIME ARBITRATION, A COMPARISON AND AN ANALYSIS
Pieter L.M. Vismans
2. INQUISITORIAL V. ADVERSARIAL APPROACHES IN JAPANESE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
Takao Tateishi (Japan)
3. HOW TO STRENGTHEN AND SUPERVISE THE ARBITRATORS IN SELF-REGULATION
Cai Hongda (China)
4. THE SIZE OF THE LAW FIRMS AND THE IMPARTIALITY OF ARBITRATORS: NEW PROBLEMS, NEW SOLUTIONS
Sergio La China (Italy)
5. BIAS – A CANDIAN PERSPECTIVE
Trevor Bishop (Canada)
6. THE DUTY OF ARBITRATORS TO ACT INDEPENDENTLY AND IMPARTIALLY UNDER ENGLISH LAW – RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
Earnest Yang (UK)
7. HUMAN RIGHTS AND MARITIME ARBITRATION
Patrick Simon (France)
8. A MODEST PROPOSAL TO INTERNATIONAL MARITIME ARBITRATION: A NEW FORUM FOR HUMAN RIGHTS DISPUTES
Anthony J. Mavronicolas (USA)
>Questions from the floor<
Palm Room
The Starlight Roof
Tuesday, October 23, 2001
0830-1700 Registration and Information Desk Open
Palm Room
0930-1015 CEDRIC BARCLAY MEMORIAL SPEECH
Jade Room Introduction by David W. Martowski
The New Millenium, Terrorism and Arbitration
Palm Room
Starlight Roof Clauses, Off-hire, etc.
Chair: Michael A. van Gelder
Timekeeper: Roger Moisey
1. NOTICE OF READINESS IN A VOYAGE CHARTER WHILST UNDERWAY IN ADVANCE OF ARRIVAL – THE POSITION AT COMMON LAW AND UNDER THE ASBATANKVOY CHARTER
John A. Schofield (UK)
2. VETTING CLAUSES
David Martowski
3. OFF-HIRE, DEDUCTIONS FROM HIRE, TANK, CLEANING, VETTING AND LETTERS OF INDEMNITY CLAUSES
A.J. Siciliano (USA)
4. A CASE OF NO GREAT CONSEQUENCES
John Weale (Canada)
5. CLAIMS FOR CONSEQUETIAL DAMAGES AND LOST PROFITS IN NEW YORK MARITIME ARBITRATION DISPUTES
Austin L. Dooley (USA)
6. A BRIEF HISTROY OF REPORTED VETTING DISPUTES
Douglas R. Burnett
>Questions from the floor<
Hilton Room
1415 – 1530 Plenary Session V - Routing of Vessel, the Controversy
Starlight Roof Continues…
Chair: Klaus C.J. Mordhorst
Timekeeper: Philip Yang
1. THE "HILL HARMONY"
Donald Davies (UK)
2. VESSEL ROUTING, NAVIGATION OR EMPLOYMENT-MASTER’S AUTHORITY AND RESPONSIBILITIES
Henry E. Engelbrecht (USA)
3. "HILL HARMONY" AND "WHITE MANTA"
Jack A. Greenbaum (USA)
>Questions from the floor<
1600 – 1730 Plenary Session VI - The ERIKA, Classification Societies and
Starlight Roof Salvage
Chair: John Maskell
Timekeeper: Peter Naschitz
1. THE ERIKA-EFFECT ON CLASSIFICATION SOCIETIES
Henri de Richemont (France)
2. PRESENT-DAY MARINE CASUALTY RESPONSE: SORTING OUT MANAGEMENT RESPONSIBILITIES
Bob Umdenstock (USA)
3. THE LIABILITY OF CLASSIFICATION SOCIETY
Thomas Tisdale (USA)
Philippe Boisson (France)
>Questions from the floor<
1830-2030 Cocktail Party, The Sky Club
Hosted by Select Members of the New York Bar
Wednesday, October 24, 2001
The Hudson River Adventure
Thursday, October 25, 2001
0830 - 1730 Registration and Information Desk Open
0930 – 1245 Plenary Session VII - More on Chartering and Maritime
Starlight Roof Arbitration…
Chair: Johannes Trappe
Timekeeper: Patrick Simon
1. DISPUTE RESOLUTION IN THE THIRD MILLENNIUM
Jorgen Rasch (Denmark)
2. DEALING WITH ISSUES RESPECTING SECURITY AND DISCOVERY – A COMPARISON OF THE ENGLISH AND THE AMERICAN APPROACHES
David A. Nourse (USA) and Andrew Taylor (UK)
3. THE WOOLF REFORMS – NEW FOR OLD IN AN INTERNATIONAL CONTEXT
Keith Michel (UK)
4. BROKERS’ AND AGENTS’ RIGHTS UNDER CHARTERS AND THE EFFECT OF NEW LEGISLATION
Charles Measter (USA)
>Questions from the floor<
1245-1415 Lunch
Hilton Room Speaker: Honorable Charles S. Haight, Jr.
U.S. Senior District Judge, Southern District of New York
1415-1715 Concurrent Session VIII - Maritime Arbitration: Evidence,
Starlight Roof Techniques and Enforcement
ROOM IS SAME FOR BOTH CONCURRENTS!!
Chair: Klaus C.J. Mordhorst
Timekeeper: Philip Yang
1. A COMPILATION OF RULES OF EVIDENCE AS A MEANS OF SPEEDY ARBITRATION
H.M. Singh (India)
2. EVIDENCE IN ARBITRATION
Bruce A. McAllister (USA)
3. ASSISTANCE OF SPANISH COURTS IN CONNECTION WITH FOREIGN ARBITRATION PROCEEDINGS
Tomas Fernandez (Spain)
4. CHALLENGES TO ARBITRATION AWARDS UNDER THE NEW YORK CONVENTION ON THE RECOGNITION AND ENFORCEMENT OF ARBITRATION AWARDS: A SURVEY OF AMERICAN CASE LAW
Armand M. Paré, Jr. (USA)
5. EFFECTS OF THE SPECIAL MARITIME PROCEDURE LAW ON MARITIME ARBITRATION
Henry Li (China)
6. AWARDING OF INTEREST ON SUMS AWARDED IN ARBITRATION AWARDS
Michael A. van Gelder (USA)
7. SOMETHING TO DO OR NOT DO?: REFLECTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ON ARBITRATORS’ MAKING AWARDS ON THE BASIS OF GROUNDS NOT ADVANCED BY THE PARTIES
Eugene McDonald (USA)
>Questions from the floor<
1415-1715 Concurrent Session IX - Carriage of Goods: Legislations,
Starlight Roof Conventions, Charter Parties and Bills of Lading
ROOM IS SAME FOR BOTH CONCURRENTS!!
Chair: Paul David
Timekeeper: Trevor Bishop
1. THE REFORM OF THE GERMAN TRANSPORT LAW
Johannes Trappe (Germany)
2. SALIENT FEATURES OF TRANSPORT CONTRACT LAW
Zhu Zengie (China)
3. GOODBYE TO THE HAGUE RULES AND ALL THAT?
David Martin-Clark (UK)
4. LIFTING THE FOG ON COLLISION LAW
Alexis Nichols (USA)
5. DEFINITION OF "CARRIER," PAST, PRESENT AND WHAT IS THE FUTURE
Michael Ryan (USA)
6. THE OLD SHELL GAME – OR WHO IS THE CARRIER?
Jorgen Rasch (Denmark)
>Questions from the floor<
Friday, October 26, 2001
0830-1300 Registration and Information Desk Open
Palm Room
0930-1145 Plenary Session X - Selecting Issues for Early Decision
Starlight Roof to Facilitate Settlement
Chair: Bruce Harris
Timekeeper: Sergio La China
1. PARTIAL AWARDS ADDRESSING NON-DISPOSITIVE ISSUES
Jack Berg (USA)
2. RECENT USE OF INTERIM AND PARTIAL FINAL AWARDS IN NEW YORK MARITIME ARBITRATION
Michael Marks Cohen (USA)
3. Jonathan Lux (UK)
4. Sir Christopher Staughton (UK)
1145-1215 Coffee Break
1215-1300 Business Meeting
Paul David, Chair (New Zealand)
Manfred W. Arnold (USA)
Patrick O’Donovan (UK)
Patrick Simon (France)
Business Meeting
Closing Comments: Manfred W. Arnold